Why is it some modeller's engines just purr along and seem so effortless about their task?
PRELUDE: This article is written
primarily to help the advanced beginner through the difficult transition to
competition flying. The information is a collection of observations and remedies
from years of experience about with stunt engines in New Zealand conditions.
It is also intended to highlight many of the simple solutions to problems before
getting seriously side tracked into engine modifications.
There is a lot written about getting engines to run well, but still every time
at stunt contests I seem to end up helping sort out models and engines. It seems
that old basic problems keep showing their faces.
There are no real secrets but my belief is that you have to KEEP THE SET-UP
SIMPLE, EASY TO MAINTAIN, and most of all BE THOROUGH ABOUT IT. A simple set-up
can take a lot of time initially but it will require the minimum of maintenance
to keep operational.
Before you get anywhere near the flying field, there are a lot of things to
check and possibly remedy, some of which would be best done in the process of
building the model. I will break it down into sections and will try to keep
it as brief as possible. Be methodical about it and check off each item when
it has been given the "Stuntman's seal of Approval'.
ENGINE MOUNTING: Mount the
engine on rigid mounts securely, preferably using additional
locknuts to avoid the bolts vibrating loose.
TANKS: Design the tank mounting to be AS CLOSE AS POSSIBLE behind the engine.
Make
provision for it to be adjustable above or below the centreline of the needle
valve. Profile
models generally require the tank to be higher than the centreline of the prop
shaft. Tank
adjustment is extremely important for "trimming" the engine run to
be equal upright and
inverted. It also helps to skew the tank sideways in the fuselage to help make
the engine cut
cleanly at the end of the run. (Back outboard corner - outboard.)
Mount the tank securely but on a layer of foam plastic to absorb some of the
vibration.
Tank construction: Some sort of symmetrical metal wedge tank. The joints MUST
be
overlapped and Clean solder joints with no leaks.
Tank Plumbing: USE uniflow venting.
Feed Pipe: This should end approximately 1.5mm from the back outside corner
of the wedge.
Uniflow Vent: This needs to be between 15 & 16mm directly forward of the
feed on the
Horizontal centreline of the tank. The vent pipe needs to exit the fuselage
above the top level
of the tank and pointing forward into the breeze. (The tank can be connected
to the exit tube
with a length of silicon fuel tubing).
The uniflow vent also serves as the filler.
Overflow Pipe: This is usually drilled through the bottom of the tank and goes
to the top
inside corner of the tank. The overflow must be BLOCKED OFF in flight with a
cap that is air
tight. Plug a piece of fuel tube with a solid rivet, bind with cotton and cyano.
Note: 1/8" or 3mm thick wall copper tube is better than the thin walled
brass tube because it
is easier to bend and it helps control fuel surging. Be sure to solder each
pipe in two places in
the tank, firstly where the pipe enters the tank and secondly where the pipe
ends inside the
tank.
After completion of soldering, flush the tank thoroughly with lots of water
to neutralise the
flux and then flush with fuel.
MUFFLER PRESSURE: DO NOT USE MUFFLER PRESSURE! I have seen people struggling
for
years using muffler pressure and it is more trouble than it is worth for stunt.
Set up your engine
to run on suction feed with a suitable sized venturi to achieve the run you
require. For .40 to .50
size engines a 7mm inside diameter venturi using a 4mm diameter needle valve
spray bar is a good
starter.
FUEL LINES: The feed line from the tank to engine must be on the OUTBOARD SIDE
of the
fuselage and the most direct route possible. i.e. On the horizontal centre line
of the needle
valve for inverted engines. Use an in-line fuel filter.
Fuel lines that can flap around are a NO GOOD. Use sensible sized fuel line,
not the 'garden
hose' variety used on large radio models. Adjust the length of the fuel line
so'-that bends are
smooth with no kinks. If the needle valve fuel tube junction or any others are
not a tight
reliable fit, wire them on with 15 Amp fuse wire or try smaller tube.
NEEDLE VALVE ASSEMBLIES: Personally
I prefer the Super Tigre style N.V.A. that has a
collet to lock the needle in position.
These should be tightened so you can just turn the needle without excessive
force. The OS.
style N.V.A. do not give a reliable setting because the needle can vibrate like
a tuning fork,
and sometimes you need a half a click!
The spray bar jet hole should be just past horizontal pointing downwards. You
should not be
able to see the hole. Periodically the needle and fuel lines need to be removed
and the spray
bar back flushed. NOT back into the tank!
FUEL CLEANLINESS: This is vitally important, filter your fuel into your bottle,
have a filter
on the outlet of your bottle and another in the model. MAKE SURE THE FILTERS
ARE
EFFECTIVE! I replace the gauze in commercial filters with much finer gauze and
ensure the
gauze is a tight fit inside the filter case so crap can't sneak around the side.
ENGINE CLEANLINESS: Remove the muffler and examine the piston through the exhaust
port while turning the engine over. If there is a brown lacquer build up on
the piston the
engine is due for a clean out. It would be wise at this stage to look at the
cooling system
because chances are the engine is running too hot. For cowled engines the outlet
area must be
considerably larger than the inlet area. As a rule of thumb the outlet should
be twice the size
of the inlet.
If you are nervous about dismantling the engine, try and find someone to help
you who knows
the "Art" of engine dismantling and cleaning. For a reliable engine
run it is important that
there is no brown lacquer build up, particularly on moving parts.
When the engine is dismantled, look carefully at the following areas:
1. Piston and the inside bore of the liner.
2. Outside of the liner and inside of the cylinder jacket.
3. Piston ring and groove.
4. Inside of the gudgeon pin hole in piston.
5. Top, little end of con-rod (bearing)
6. Edge of cylinder head / combustion chamber that slips into the liner.
I like to put all the parts
in a sealed golden syrup tin or screw top jar to soak for several days in lacquer
thinners.
To remove the lacquer from holes, wrap a small piece of 1,200 grit wet &
dry paper (2,000 grit is better) around a suitable sized drill shank so it just
slides into the hole. VERY CAREFULLY sand trying not to remove any metal.
After spot sanding the worst areas, the internal bore of the liner can be done
in a similar way with 400 - 600 wet & dry paper wrapped around a piece of
smoothly machined bar for support. Sand in a spiral pattern in both directions.
Check that the piston ring is free in its groove If gummed up it should be very
carefully removed and the ring plus the groove cleaned.
The external parts of the engine that are castor oil baked can be cleaned by
boiling them in a pot with a teaspoon of Cold Water Surf or dishwasher powder
for 10 to 15 minutes then scrubbing well with an old toothbrush. This also works
well for the piston and liner but avoid this treatment on ball races. After
this, scrub everything thoroughly in a tin of white spirits or kerosene and
flush parts individually with a squeeze bottle, placing them to drain on a clean
newspaper.
Reassemble the engine, then before fitting the cylinder head and back plate,
flush the engine one last time and give it a squirt of CRC 5.56, WD4O or sewing
machine oil. Ensure the cylinder head and back plate gaskets seal properly and
the screws are tightened evenly.
The engine will take about 6 runs for the moving parts to seat in again and
you will probably need to lean out each run. Once run in, the oil from the exhaust
should be clean. If it is not then something in the engine is wearing or the
muffler is loose.
FUEL: For the purposes of the tests on the flying field (coming eventually...)
it is essential
that you "KEEP THE FUEL BREW CONSISTENT"
For most engines's. a mix containing 5% Nitro, 20% Castor Oil and 75% Methanol
is a good
guide. Plain bearing engines should have a little extra oil, 22.5%. It is not
usually necessafy in
the New Zealand climate to run higher oil contents that you read about in American
articles
because we don't have to contend with the very hot conditions.
Older ringed piston engines
and those with cast iron piston/steel bore should have fuel containing Castor
Oil or at least 10% Castor Oil if Synthetic oil is used. Like everything, Castor
Oil has disadvantages but it seems to give the engine run a sweetness that synthetic
oil doesn't.
You might have noticed some of the Tro's" putting a squirt of "Armor
ALL" (Silicone spray) in their fuel can. This acts as an anti foaming agent
and is a good idea to help eliminate foaming fuel caused by engine vibration.
The tiniest drop in a litre of fuel is sufficient but note that it needs to
be done before you go flying because it does not seem to last long periods.
GLOW PLUGS: Forget the "OS No.8" cliche or at least turn it into and
05 No.7! There are no hard and fast rules, in fact if you really know your stuff
you can set up an engine to run satisfactory on almost any glow plug heat. However
on the fuel suggested containing 5% Nitro, a MIEDIIJM HEAT plug is where to
start. A lot of people use plugs that are too hot and their engines behave too
aggressively.
In the flight testing I will
describe glow plugs in more detail but for now I thoroughly recommend you try
an 05 No.7 Idle bar plug. This is the plug that I have success with and it seems
to have helped sort out numerous problem engines over the years I have flown
stunt.
Idle bar plugs offer advantages for engine runs where the engine is breaking
from 4 stroke (rich) to 2 stroke (lean) to control the speed of the model through
manoeuvres. On smaller engines and those set up to run at a constant relatively
high RPM, standard plugs are OK. The 05 No.3 is very similar to the No.7 but
is a standard non-idle bar plug.
The Firepower range is also worth a try. I have a complete set for testing engines
and there is an excellent selection of heat ranges. e.g. Cold, Cool, Medium,
Warm, Hot. I use the set to determine where to start with adjusting fuel and
compression ratio.
PROPELLERS: Props must be balanced. My preference is for wooden propellers because
they
are very light and do not act like a flywheel. The object is to have the engine
relatively lightly
loaded so that it will gently switch from rich to lean and vice versa when required.
Heavy
plastic props load the engine up delaying this action that will mean the power
will turn on or
switch off too late!
For most engine / model combinations, pitches between 5" and 6" will
generally work best. The
manufacture's instructions will guide you with the approximate diameters to
work with. Some
engines will tolerate being really loaded down with big props but it pays to
avoid this if you can
because if the engine is working hard it introduces additional problems, e.g.
overheating,
lacquering of the internal engine parts which in turn leads to poor inconsistent
runs.
FLIGHT TESTING: If you are still with us we are now probably ready to start
flight testing
to tune the engine correctly for the model, and the flier!
Begin trials by fitting a medium glow plug and set the engine to a comfortable
speed so that
the model will not 'fall out of the sky" when doing basic manoeuvres like
loops. Prop the engine
so it is not too heavily loaded. On a 35 to 60 powered model at 60 ft to 70
ft line length, this
equates to about 5 to 5.5 second laps, 50-60 mph. It is a rare model that can
be trimmed to
fly safely with speeds lower than this, i.e. higher lap times.
Lap times: With the help of a timekeeper, time the lap times both upright and
inverted. The
object is to have them identical. If the engine run inverted is SLOWER (richer)
than upright
then the tank needs to be adjusted or shimmed higher in the fuselage. If it
is FASTER
inverted then the tank needs to be lowered. It is important to get this even
before going any
further.
It is also useful to time the lap times early in the run and late in the run
preferably on a flight
Where a schedule is flown so the engine is working normally. If the engine is
speeding up
towards the end of the run (getting leaner) then it could mean the engine is
running too hot. If
a uniflow tank system is used, with the overflow blocked off airtight, the problem
is most
likely with the engine.
Look carefully at the cooling system and improve it if you can. Next you can
experiment with
Plug heats, trying a hotter plug first.
If the engine is slower towards the end of the run (getting richer) then the
engine is
overcooling. If the model is still safely flyable, leave this for the time being
but at a later
stage if it still persists then the oil content can be lowered slightly. I have
had to go as low as
17% oil content to cure this problem with some engines.
4/2 Stroke switching: The
next steps involve a lot of flight trials to tune the engine to suit
your flying style. Try flying loops or horizontal eights not worrying too much
about quality of
shape and keeping a little higher than normal so that you can "focus your
ears" on the engine
run. Listen to the note of the engine as the model climbs into a loop and goes
over the top and
down again. If you are running the engine slightly rich so that it is 4 stroking
in level flight
then the aim is for the engine to gently switch lean as the model climbs into
a loop. The engine
should then softly switch back to rich as the model starts to descend in the
second half of
the loop to govern the speed of the model.
If the engine stays lean right through the loop or switches off too late so
the loops gradually
get faster and faster and it's a grim matter of hanging on by the third loop
then something
definitely needs to be changed!
At this stage I usually do some simple glow plug trials to determine what to
do with the
compression ratio and/or Nitro content in the fuel. To play safe, try a warmer
plug first but I
suspect in a lot of cases a cooler plug might tame the engine to something nearer
comfortable.
When I first flight tested my Moki 51 it required a cold plug for it to perform
somewhere
near normal! If the change of plug heat makes a big difference it tells us what
we can do next.
I now like to tune the engine to run on my favourite glow plug, the OS No.7,
medium heat, idle
bar.
If you find a cooler plug is necessary to remove the aggressiveness from the
engine run so it
"purrs" then it tells us the compression ratio is too high. Make or
purchase some head shims
and keep adding them until the switching from rich to lean and back to rich
in loops are just at
the right points on the loop to achieve an even comfortable model speed. You
can also lower
the Nitro content in the fuel but it is wise to have at least 2-3% to ease starting,
because in
stunt, starting IS a manoeuvre!
If a warmer glow plug is necessary then you could if you want to, run a higher
Nitro content or
higher compression but these are not really necessary and it would be easiest
to stay with a
warm or hot plug heat.
Once you arrive at the combination that suits you it is vitally important you
stick with the
same fuel brew. Even a change of oil content or change from castor to synthetic
oil is enough
to throw everything out of balance. For example if you change from using a fuel
with castor oil
to a fuel with a blend of castor-synthetic, the engine run will change dramatically
and you will
probably need to lower the compression ratio further.
Most engines for stunt seem to tolerate quite a lot of decompression to remove
aggressiveness from the run. My Moki 51 required an extra 0.5mm (0.020")
of head shims to
make me reasonably happy. It was obviously factory set for straight FAI 80/20
fuel.
GENERAL: In reality changing plug heat, Nitro content in fuel and compression
ratio can all
achieve the same thing. In the end it is usually a combination of all three
that is most
practical.
Propellers will make a big difference to the engine run. When you start to get
results with the
engine set up, try lowering the pitch of the prop to gear the engine down a
little so that the
engine will have more freedom to switch. If you can run 5" pitch you will
most probably be
surprised by how much more lively the model feels.
In most cases the changes I have described will improve the majority of engines
being used.
You can experiment further with venturi sizes and if really serious, change
the exhaust and
transfer timing, but I have not intended this article to delve that deeply,
trying to
concentrate on the simple solutions.
Lastly, it is important to use an after run oil following a day's flying. For
quite a number of
years I have gotten into the habit of sucking the last few drops of unused fuel
from the tank
then squirting CRC 5.56 into the venturi, flicking the prop to disperse it through
the engine. I
then plug the venturi and exhaust with a wad of tissue paper. At the same time
give your
control lines a squirt and put them in a sealed plastic bag. However you need
to use a more
permanent oil for long storage of engines, but CRC or WD4O is fine for several
months. Apart
from keeping the engine free, it penetrates the needle valve and stops oil setting
in there.
If you forget to do this treatment you will find the first run(s) of the day
will be lean as the
fuel flow cleanses the needle valve assembly. By using the after run treatment
you should not
have to make needle adjustments as often.
If you can persevere and sort out the engine department you will remove a lot
of worry so
that you can concentrate on the FLYING!!!